ptc24: (Default)
Peter ([personal profile] ptc24) wrote in [personal profile] pseudomonas 2016-10-28 01:06 pm (UTC)

I'm thinking back to ancient Athens, what was the vote... ah yes, Mytilene.

The Athenians had captured Mytilene - a city-state that had tried to escape from their hegemony. They wondered what to do about it, and there was a vote on the matter, and they voted to exterminate all the men and sell the rest into slavery. A ship was sent out with the orders to carry this out.

The next day some Athenians had a change of heart, and narrowly voted not to do that. A second ship was sent out, with a double crew for extra speed and through-the-night rowing, and reached Mytilene in the nick of time.

With Parliament, or Athenian-style direct democracy, or other setups where decisions can be swiftly made and remade, there's always a chance of changing your mind, when the consequences of a policy become clearer. The trouble with referenda is they take a lot of time and money to redo... and the winning side is often very reluctant to allow a re-run. It's like they want a broken decision-making system.

I'll give the ardent Brexiteers one thing - if you wanted to play Chicken with the EU, then having a referendum and then being ardent about not having another one is a way of trying to implement the "throw the steering wheel out of the car" gambit. Whether or not this is a good thing to be doing is left as an exercise for the reader.

Post a comment in response:

If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

If you are unable to use this captcha for any reason, please contact us by email at support@dreamwidth.org